Common KPIs Tracked in R&D Organizations:
As a continuation of Part 1 of our 2 part series:"Maximizing R&D Success: Tracking & Measuring Performance Metrics" we go beyond the importance of tracking and measuring KPIs in R&D, and take a deeper dive into the different categories of metrics along with the specific KPIs that are commonly used to track and measure the performance of R&D organizations.
In part 2 of this series, we'll outline the 7 main groups of performance metrics (listed below), provide a few examples of different KPIs that fall under each group, their implications, and how to calculate and/or evaluate them.
1. Innovation Metrics
2. Time-to-Market Metrics
3. Financial Metrics
4. Cost Metrics
5. Safety, Regulatory, & Compliance Metrics
6. Product Improvement Metrics
7. Talent & Service Metrics
1. Innovation Metrics
Innovation metrics measure the impact of R&D efforts on the organization's overall innovation strategy helping to provide insights into the success of R&D in driving business growth and creating a competitive advantage. These metrics may include:
- Cost Spent on Innovation: Total Cost Spent on Innovation: Represents the resources allocated to research, development, and other activities aimed at creating and implementing new ideas, products, services, or processes. This metric provides insights into the organization's commitment to innovation and can be used to assess the effectiveness of innovation-related investments and track trends in innovation spending over time.
◦ Sum of all innovation-related expenses to obtain the total cost spent on innovation - Number of New Products Launched in a Given Time: Provides insights into a company's innovation and product development capabilities. A higher number of new products launched indicates a higher level of innovation and market responsiveness, while a lower number may suggest slower product development or fewer resources dedicated to innovation.
◦ Total count of unique products that have been introduced by a company during a specified period (this can include entirely new products, line extensions, product variations, or updates/improvements to existing products). - Number of Patents Filed: Provides insights into the company's commitment to innovation and intellectual property protection. It's important to note that while the number of patents filed is a valuable metric, it should be considered in conjunction with other indicators, such as the quality and success rate of patent applications, granted patents, and the impact of patented inventions on business growth and market differentiation.
◦ Identify and count all the patent applications that were filed by your company within a chosen time frame, then sum the total counted patent filings during a specified time period - Revenue Generated from New Products/Innovations: Measures the financial impact of new products or innovations on a company's revenue. It reflects the success of these new offerings in generating income and driving business growth.
◦ Sum up the revenue generated from all the identified *sources within the chosen time frame (*revenue sources could include sales figures from new product lines, revenue generated by product variations, or any other income attributable to recently introduced offerings). - New Product Development Success Rate: The effectiveness of a company's product development processes and the ability to deliver successful new products or innovations. A higher success rate indicates a higher level of efficiency in identifying market needs, designing products, and bringing them to market successfully. It reflects the company's capacity to innovate and execute product development strategies that yield positive outcomes.
◦ [(Number of New Products/Innovations) / (Total Number of New Products Developed During Specified Time Frame)] x 100
Innovation metrics provide a way for organizations to measure the success of their innovation efforts and identify areas for improvement. By tracking these metrics, organizations can ensure that they are investing in the right areas, developing products that meet customer needs, and ultimately driving growth and profitability.
2. Time-to-Market Metrics
Time-to-Market (TTM) metrics are crucial for R&D organizations as they enable them to measure the speed and efficiency of their product development process. These metrics may include:
- Time-to-market per Product: The speed or efficiency with which a company can bring a new product to the market. It quantifies the time it takes from the initiation of the product development process to the product's availability for sale or launch. A shorter time indicates greater efficiency and competitiveness.
◦ Sum of The Time Spent From Phase 0 {Concept Phase} to Phase 4 {Market Release} - Average Time-to-Market for New Products: Measures the average duration it takes for a company to bring new products to market. It quantifies the average time it takes from the initiation of the product development process to the availability of the products for sale or launch.
◦ (Sum of Individual Time-to-Market Durations) / (Total Number of New Products Launched) - Time-to-market Innovation Pipeline: Measures the quantity and quality of new ideas, projects, or innovations that are in various stages of development within an organization. It provides insights into the company's capacity to continuously generate and nurture a robust pipeline of innovative initiatives.
◦ Determine the different stages or phases that represent the progression of ideas or projects within your organization's innovation pipeline, track the number of initiatives at each stage, then sum up the counts from all the stages to obtain the total number of initiatives in the innovation pipeline.
Time-to-market metrics measure the speed and efficiency of the R&D process from idea generation to product launch. TTM metrics enable R&D organizations to improve the speed and efficiency of their product development processes while maintaining or improving product quality. This can result in cost savings, increased productivity, and a better competitive position in the market.
3. Financial Metrics
Tracking financial metrics allows organizations to evaluate the financial return on investment (ROI) for their R&D activities. By tracking the costs of R&D projects against their outcomes, organizations can determine whether their R&D investments are generating positive returns. These metrics may include:
- R&D as a Percentage of Sales: How much of income is spent on creating new products (or the investment in enhancing existing products). Research shows correlation between companies who dedicate a greater percent of their income to R&D having greater customer satisfaction and greater market share.
◦ (R&D Expenditure x 100) / (Gross Company Sales) - Cost Variance: The R&D cost variance formula helps in evaluating the cost performance of an R&D project or program. The resulting variance ratio represents the deviation or difference between the actual costs and the planned costs, relative to the planned costs expressed as a percentage. .
◦ (Actual Costs - Planned Costs) / (Planned Costs)
- Innovation Effectiveness: Provides an indication of the completion rate or progress of R&D projects. The resulting percentage indicates the proportion of projects that have successfully finished development out of all the projects that have entered the development phase.
◦ [(Number of Projects Finishing Development) / (Number of Projects Beginning Development)] x 100 - R&D Effectiveness Index (RDEI): Measures the effectiveness of a company's R&D activities over the past five years. The resulting index indicates the efficiency and success of the company's R&D efforts in generating revenue from the products developed.
◦ (Present Value of Revenue Generated From Products Developed in Last 5 Years) / (Present Value of Last 5 Years Cumulative R&D Costs)
Financial metrics help organizations identify areas of inefficiency or waste in its R&D processes and provide insights into the financial health of the organization as a whole. By tracking financial metrics R&D organizations can make informed decisions about resource allocation, optimize their operations, and ensure financial sustainability.
4. Cost Metrics
Cost metrics measure the efficiency of R&D spending and the return on investment (ROI) of R&D efforts. These metrics may include:
- R&D Costs: The financial investment allocated to research and development (R&D) activities within an organization. It quantifies the expenses incurred in conducting R&D efforts, including personnel, equipment, facilities, materials, and other associated costs.
◦ Sum of all the cost components associated with R&D activities within your organization (e.g., personnel salaries, research equipment, laboratory expenses, material costs, outsourcing expenses, and any other relevant expenses). - Cost per Project: Measures the average expenditure incurred for each individual research and development (R&D) project within an organization. It helps assess the efficiency and financial impact of R&D initiatives. A lower cost per project generally indicates better cost efficiency and effective resource allocation, implying that the organization is achieving its R&D objectives while utilizing its resources optimally. However, it's important to assess the context of each project and the desired outcomes to understand the implications of the cost per project.
◦ (Total R&D Costs) / (Number of R&D Projects) - Cost Savings Attributable to R&D: Represents the monetary value of cost reductions or savings directly attributable to the outcomes of R&D initiatives. It captures the financial benefits gained by the organization as a result of R&D efforts, such as improved processes, streamlined operations, enhanced technologies, or optimized resource utilization. However, it's important to assess the context of each project and the desired outcomes to understand the implications of the cost per project.
◦ Sum of the cost savings for each component for a specified time frame
Cost metrics allow for better cost management and resource allocation. By tracking and analyzing cost metrics, companies can identify areas to reduce costs and optimize their R&D budget, leading to increased profitability and a better return on investment.
5. Safety, Regulatory, & Compliance Metrics
Safety, regulatory, & compliance metrics are crucial for R&D organizations that deal with products or services that may impact public safety or fall under regulatory scrutiny.
- Data Quality & Accuracy: Represents the overall assessment of the quality and accuracy of data within the organization. It encompasses various dimensions of data quality, such as completeness, correctness, consistency, validity, timeliness, and relevance.
◦ This metric is subjective & relies on qualitative assessments vs. quantitative calculations. - Time to Protocol Approval: The elapsed time from the submission of a research protocol or study proposal to its approval by the relevant authorities or ethics committees within the organization. It captures the duration required for the approval process, including reviews, revisions, and any necessary approvals or clearances.
◦. (Total Duration for all Protocols) / (Number of Protocols) - ISO 9001-Specific KPIs: ISO 9001-Specific Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) are performance metrics that are specifically aligned with the requirements and principles of the ISO 9001 quality management system standard. ISO 9001 is an internationally recognized standard that sets out the criteria for implementing an effective quality management system within an organization. These KPIs help monitor and assess the performance of quality management processes and activities. The calculation of ISO 9001-specific KPIs may vary based on the specific requirements and context of each organization, but here are some commonly used examples:
◦ Customer Satisfaction
◦ Process Efficiency
◦ Corrective Actions and Preventive Actions (CAPA)
◦ Nonconformities or Defects
◦ Internal Audit Findings
◦ Employee Training and Competence
Safety, regulatory, & compliance metrics are important for R&D organizations because they help to ensure that products are safe and compliant with applicable regulations and standards. One of the key benefits of safety, regulatory, & compliance metrics is that they help to mitigate risks associated with product development and release, helping to improve product development processes and reduce the time and cost associated with bringing products to market.
6. Product Improvement Metrics
Product improvements are a key area for R&D organizations, as they drive innovation and competitiveness in the market.
- Average Time to Modify an Existing Product vs. Greenfield Development (developing a system for a new environment): Compares the average time required to make modifications or updates to an existing product with the average time taken for developing a completely new product from scratch (greenfield development). It provides insights into the relative efficiency and speed of product modification versus developing new products.
◦ Average Time for Product Modification = (Total Time for Product Modifications) / (Number of Modified Products)
◦ Average Time for Greenfield Development =(Total Time for Greenfield Development) / (Number of New Products) - Return on Investment (ROI) Payback Period: The time it takes for the accumulated profits from a new product to equal or surpass the total development costs invested in creating that product. The ROI Payback Period provides insights into the financial viability and efficiency of the new product.
◦ (Total Development Costs) / (Average Monthly {or Annual} Profits) - Product Adoption Rate: Represents the percentage or proportion of target customers or users who have adopted or started using the new product within a specific time frame. It indicates the degree to which the market embraces the product and demonstrates its value proposition.
◦ [(Number of Adopters) / (Total Potential Customers or Users)] x 100
Product improvement metrics are essential for R&D organizations because they provide valuable insights into how well a product performs in the market and where improvements can be made to increase its success. By tracking these metrics, companies can measure the effectiveness of their product development efforts and identify opportunities to optimize and enhance their products.
7. Talent & Service Metrics
Talent metrics measure the performance of R&D personnel and the effectiveness of talent management strategies. These metrics may include:
- Employee Turnover Rate: Represents the percentage of employees who leave the R&D department or team within a defined time frame, typically on an annual basis. It provides insights into the stability, retention, and engagement of R&D personnel and can have implications on your organizations ability to capture and optimize on R&D efforts.
◦ [(Number of Employees Who Left) / (Average Number of Employees)] x 100 - Human Capital “Knowledge” Captured: Measures the extent to which the knowledge and expertise of R&D personnel are documented, stored, and made accessible within the organization. It reflects the ability to preserve and leverage valuable intellectual capital as well as capture and leverage the intellectual capital of employees involved in research and development activities. The calculation of this KPI can vary depending on the specific approach and tools used to capture and document knowledge:
◦ Documentation and knowledge management systems (e.g.Laboratory Information Management Systems “LIMS")
◦ Employee knowledge contributions
◦ Expertise mapping
◦ Employee surveys or assessments
Talent metrics help R&D teams ensure they have the right people with the right skills to drive innovation and achieve organizational goals. A lower level of knowledge captured may imply gaps in knowledge management processes, limited documentation practices, or challenges in knowledge transfer within the organization. It underscores the importance of implementing knowledge capture and sharing initiatives to preserve critical knowledge assets, enable efficient collaboration, and foster continuous learning.
How Often Are KPIs Tracked?
The frequency at which R&D KPIs are monitored and evaluated may differ depending on an organization's size, objectives, and resources. Nevertheless, a widely recognized best practice is to conduct regular reviews and assessments of these KPIs, typically on a quarterly basis. This helps ensure that R&D activities align with the company's strategic objectives and the competitive landscape of the industry. By regularly measuring and assessing performance, companies can remain agile and swiftly adjust their R&D strategies as required.
How to Innovate Faster & Track KPIs Effectively
Overall, end-to-end platforms like Uncountable offer a powerful solution that help R&D organizations to collect, manage, and analyze data more effectively, while also enabling greater collaboration and accessibility to data that’s captured across the entire organization. As a result of greater efficiency and collaboration, Uncountable’s platform unlocks additional data that provide insight into the efficacy of R&D operations.
While other solutions solely dedicated to tracking and monitoring KPIs exist, these are often systems that live separately from laboratory data and information management systems. Systems that often require scientists to re-enter information again or in some cases, operate independently from the actual R&D work scientists are performing – ultimately making it difficult to attain reliable and consistent performance data. Therefore, while Uncountable’s platform is not solely a tool to track and generate KPIs, our platform provides an all-in-one solution that encompasses tools that are enable R&D teams to track KPIs while directly tying those KPIs back to their innovation efforts.
Implementing an end-to-end data management system is a proactive approach to effective R&D management resulting in superior innovation, greater competitiveness, and increased long-term success in the constantly changing business environment. By automating data collection and analysis, providing advanced analytics tools, and enabling collaboration, these platforms can help organizations achieve their R&D goals and deliver better products and services to their customers.
Click here to read Part 1: "Maximizing R&D Success: Tracking & Measuring Performance Metrics"
.jpg)
.jpg)
